You can tell this is an ancient meme because it prices college at 4 years at $9,000 per year instead of 5 years at $30,000 per year 😆
Cool leave all the executive and judicial positions for the children of the rich. They’ll make ethical decisions that benefit everyone
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
abolish the state
That’s where the dictatorship of the people comes in.
Frankly, this is where I borrow a page from Mao’s Little Red Book. If you had the sort of education that only wealth and privilege can grant you, you have no right to hold political power.
Your words are self-defeating. A dictatorship is based on privilege for the few.
Also: Your only solution for classism is put some power concentration on it?
One Worker to rule them all, One Worker to find them, One Worker to bring them all and in the darkness bind them.
Few things here. Apprenticeships are hard to come by. You have to know someone or be in the right family already.
Second, university is a universal education. You can do almost anything afterwards. Gradschool is where you have to pick something. But some folks do multiple post grads. If you pick apprenticeship, that’s it. That’s the thing you’re doing. Forever.
Personaly, I’m very happy to have a well rounded education. I became a software engineer 10 years after graduting university. I could do it, and could get hired for it, because of that education. All the skills you hone at university helped me alonng the way, writing, speaking, critical thinking, I even leaned to sail and fence.
Apprenticeships give you a single trade, university teaches you how to think, and makes you a better person.
On top of that, apprenticeships are job training, and a unuversity education is… Not. And no number of 17 year old high school honours students, or their parents, or high school teachers, or university recruitment offices, or corporate HR departments have actually or will actually change that. And that’s not to say there’s anything inherently wrong with job training, but so much of the discourse around university’s “usefulness” always boils down to “you spend all of this money, and they still don’t teach you to do the job”, which… Yeah. You don’t get fried chicken from a tailor’s shop, either.
Moreover, one of the key reasons university education is so damn expensive is because rich dicks don’t want the poors getting one. And while they’ve managed to spin public perception of university as job training, and as a result managed to get people to go deeply into debt to target specific, non-comprehensive or non-critical degree programs, it remains true that a high level liberal education is soemthing they don’t want us to have.
Because it gives us the tools to see through their lies and bullshit.
All we need to do is look at the degree programs they shit on most strongly: They’re all rooted in examining and criticising social power dynamics. In response to that, they tell us that they’ll be excited to “order their happy meals” from people perusing those fields.
Which, of course, isn’t exactly rooted in falsehood, because most well paying businesses don’t want to have people around who are trained in recognizing and criticising power dynamics.
Because they’re abusive systems in and of themselves, run by people who don’t want their power criticised or checked.
But that doesn’t mean the ability to do so isn’t unspeakably invaluable to society. But in a society run by entitled, unworthy assholes, the last thing they want is a populace who can recognize both that they have no place in a healthy society, and also the knowledge and gumption to create a healthy society and remove them from it.
Ha, I studied philosophy. It was perfect for becoming a bartender. But also perfect for becoming a successful software engineer out of the blue at 30.
Thank you for these expanded points. I only talked about the pregmatics and my own experience, but all of what you said is extremely important and true.
Yeah, anyone can pick up a book and learn how to string code commands together. Not everyone who does so bothers to learn why they’re doing it, or how to think through the implications of doing so. We see that over and over again in Silicon Valley today.
I imagine a philosophy background makes for well considered projects. I have a friend who was a developer in high school, who instead went into philosophy because he found his work absolutely soulless. No one he worked with wanted to think about what they were doing or why.
I used to think like that. As times passes I’m increasingly starting to agree with what you are saying. Sadly I do still think that is a matter of choice. There are poorly valued college educations and not all off them are philosophy and literature. I don’t see anything wrong with them existing like you said, they teach people critical thinking and improve people overall. But like you said the lie that education exists to give us jobs exists and there are people going to college to learn not very lucrative things and expecting to make a living out them and coming out with dept and can’t find an occupation that provides for them. Honestly I think the only way to go around that problem is to make University universal and free. That way you can always go back for something more lucrative or later in life to learn something that makes you grow.
Absolutely. Education at all levels is a boon to society at large, and it should be freely available to all. An educated populace makes the world a better, more equitable, and forward progressing palce.
An uneducated populace allows people exploit us all, and keep us working for their benefit, and not society’s.
This is elitist trash mentality my guy. It’s not that serious and you can gain life skills from anywhere. Happy you found it through the medium of uni, but lmao.
No, you really don’t learn good critical thinking or argumentative writing from anywhere. This is precisely why most of the population can be tricked into voting against their own self interests. Furthermore, this shouldn’t be seen as elitist, as this level of education should be available to everyone. The only reason it’s not is the previous point I made.
That’s just insanely retarded to say and why it’s elitist to think you can only learn this from a college/uni. I guess literally every successful dropout never learned critical thinking, or self taught, or naturally skeptic, or literally any fucking human in the past where further education wasn’t as readily accessible to the general population but still became renowned philosophers and inventors. “Sorry kids unless you spend borrowed money to indebt yourself for life you’ll always be stupid unlike me” L
It’s a predisposition to intelligence not that you had to pay for a glorified tutor. Shut the fuck up lmao.
deleted by creator
What college did you go to?
Dumbass acts like he’s never met the kids who go to college without learning a fuckin thing because they simply aren’t intelligent people.
This isn’t a universal experience that you just magically absorb a new profound understanding of the world by stepping over the threshold of the classroom door. All those liberal arts majors sure are critical thinkers bro.
My god, remove your personal bias and actually read the shit you say disconnected then tell me you aren’t elitist as fuck. I’m done with this bad faith and menial retardation blinded by your own worldview. Scum.
Apprenticeships are infinitely more competitive than college applications. Not to say that the quality of education isn’t much better, too, but most mentors are already swamped with dozens of apprenticeship requests. It’s so competitive that most will expect you to already have some familiarity with the trade, whereas most colleges go into your education assuming you have very little experience with it.
Edit
Also
$19-$23 hour paid apprenticeships
Lmao only in already high COL areas. Plus having to compete with the 1,000+ other applicants (see above). Plus “we’ll select a candidate in 4-6 months.” Plus “must provide own tools. Our shop only allows Snap-On brand, here’s a $2,200 shopping list in case you get chosen.” Also “oh yeah that position was already filled last month, so-and-so’s son just got out of rehab and needed a job.”
T. An actual tradie of nearly a decade who has a proper 4 year university degree and tech school certification
Electrician in IBEW here in a poor rural region. Those pay numbers are pretty close to our current rates, actually. And if you can pass a test, you can get into the apprenticeship program pretty easily. They don’t expect much from first year apprentices. I had a trade school diploma and my Limited Liability Electrician license already when I applied, but it didn’t matter much. The competitiveness is very dependent on your local.
You gotta buy your own hand tools, but power tools, conduit benders, etc are all provided.
So… like with everything career-related, it’s gonna depend on where you live.
‘Appreciceships’ is a pretty broad thing too. I can think of more mechanics and carpenters I know that had to buy their own tools then plumber and electricians.
deleted by creator
This is pretty representative of my area as well. The thing that is weird for me is that they priced it at 40 hrs per week. A friend of mine was an Electrician Apprentice and he worked 21 days in a row 10 hrs per day and he’s in a union.
Damn, that kinda OT is some good money but miss me with that. After 50 hours of solid work in a week I’m worthless lol.
But I do light commercial construction mostly, which is pretty go-go-go all day long with bird-dogging foremen. If I was doing industrial or large commercial there’s usually some more breathing room.
Yeah I said the same, but he was pretty pumped for it. Apparently it’s not so bad when you get out of the apprentice phase, but this is one of the concessions that their union makes. Essentially, the job has to get done by the deadline. The pros of it is that they have better benefits than government workers (his wife is a teacher), as an apprentice he was making $80k/year in 2019, and they were paying for him to go to night school for certifications (and giving him the time to do so).
I’m not sure on the classifications of work, but the kinds of jobs they did were things Amazon warehouses.
What would Bernie Sanders do?
Where are you from? I am a carpenter from Ontario, Canada and I was an apprentice in the carpenters union for a few years. They literally hired me on the spot when I sent them my resume. I also worked with a 19 year old kid who’d never had a job in his life before being hired instantly when he walked into the union hall.
Also the pay started as $20 an hour for first years, and went up about $5 an hour for every year of experience. I think if I remember correctly journeymen made around $45 an hour with benefits, and my zone wasn’t a super high COL area.
Maybe depends what apprenticeship you’re looking for but in my experience the carpenters union was dying for guys.
Bro. Be more specific about where and what apprenticeship you are talking about. You’re casting a wide web as if all the apprenticeships are in the same position. My specific trades of electrician and instrumentation are highly in demand in lots of places in Canada. Can’t speak for everywhere, but there are a lot of large construction projects going on now that can’t find workers.
The availability of apprenticeships are based off the economy vs going to school is based on whether you can afford it.
In Switzerland, apprenticeship is the standard for a good middle class income. It’s a win-win situation for all involved and if you later feel like you want to go further in your career, there’s a “master” training for your profession, which is considered by employers as equivalent to a master degree from an university. I’m not sure why such a system is not more popular in other countries.
Possibly has to do with status as pretty much since forever, university schooling has been a separator of middle class and “elite” (culturally) even though it has been made to be accessible by most people. At least one possible theory.
I have to strongly disagree here. It was the case until neoliberalism hit hard on the country. From the middle 90s, the apprenticeship isn’t the standard to a good living anymore. We have roughly half of the households which are poor or near powerty. If the apprenticeship was a gold standard, it would not be the case. Teenagers learned it very well as they prefer to choose to study even after an apprenticeship.
Everything has took an exponential price hike. Healthcare insurance, rent, food, energy and more skyrocket and living is more and more difficult if you don’t have a tertiary diploma.
You can tell this is an ancient meme because you somehow expect “non-full-time job” position to be worthwhile in any shape or form. If it’s not a full-time position, my personal belief is that either 1) they’re probably going to screw you over somehow, or 2) the government regulations are going to screw you over. (I’m in Finland. The government’s going to screw you over if you do anything besides staring at the phone and accept the first full-time position that miraculously comes your way. In recent years, they invented a new activity: SPAM JOB APPLICATIONS. This has not worked as well the government thinks it did.)
This is beyond inaccurate…
So infographics are memes now… Seriously?
Because people are bastardized the meaning of the word.
This doesn’t work for some fields imo. I don’t know how I could train someone in computer science if they don’t even know how a for loop works yet.
Senior dev: "Hey junior… " waves a piece of paper “The fuck is this?”
Junior Dev: “My code, boss.”
SD: squints
JD: “I couldn’t figure out how to email it.”
SD: squints
JD: …
SD: “Why is there a picture of a cat?”
JD: “It’s Scratch, sir.”
I’m dying lmao
There is a non-null chance the Senior Developer is an absolute God at scratch.
This is so accurate it hurts
It’s a regular thing in Germany.
Our apprenticeships are a lot cheaper though, below minimum wage, so it’s easier for the employer to set aside time for training that doesn’t earn money.
Well maybe you couldn’t, but that doesn’t mean there’s no way to set up appropriate technical instruction infrastructure as part of a union or guild through which this apprenticeship would go. Or even that one doesn’t already exist.
Often, a plumbing or electrical apprentice will come up through a technical high school. Either a technical high school or a technicial continuing education program at a community college, say.
Heck my local technical high school offers an “Information Technology” vocational program that sounds an awful lot like that program I went through in college. Wouldn’t it have been great to save 4 years and countless dollars?
For programming jobs, this gap is currently mostly filled with “bootcamps.” Increasingly you’ll find bootcamp programs that are free but garnish your salary for some time after you’ve been placed in a job, or the bootcamp is run by a company directly and you get paid to go through the bootcamp after signing a contract saying you’ll work for them for a year or two afterward or else need to pay back the price of the program.
These can vary from “pretty good, actually” to “predatory” to “a little bit like indentured servitude.” Wouldn’t it be great if there were a union or guild around these practices? Or to encourage more kids to enter trade schools that offer vocational programs they’re interested in?
I agree. I guess what I’m getting at is some fields require requisite knowledge to be useful as an apprentice on day one.
Like for an electrician, on day one you can hand me tools, pull wires, carry supplies, clean up behind me, measure, etc. You may not be able to design the layout or check that things are to code, but you can help me while I e.g. explain why I needed you to grab 3-1 wire instead of a 2-1 for this fixture.
Where as in software you need a requisite amount of knowledge to do anything useful. And it’s hard to sit there and explain what I’m doing when they can’t read the language. It could be done, it’s just harder to bring on someone that’s going to be paid when they can’t do much. I’d do it, but convincing the bean counters will be a lot harder
You’re right, you’re probably not gonna go from rando 18 year old who has only ever used an iPhone for their computing needs to even someone who can do even the “college intern” grunt work of a software dev team.
The typical on-ramp in our industry for someone like that is to come up through the help desk or data center where you do get to pull wires, carry supplies, rack and stack, manage inventory, etc. And probably this is where many apprenticeships would begin, too, if the person had literally no prerequisite knowledge.
But the bootcamp system to create devs directly is also fine. I’d just love to see more worker-oriented structure around it so we don’t have cheapass bootcamps flooding the job market with people that perhaps have the bare minimum skills and only on paper. Or predatory bootcamps locking people into jobs at shitty companies that teach them awful ways of working that their next company has to undo.
It really, really, really doesn’t take a 4 year Computer Science degree from a university to work a typical software engineer job. I’ve worked with folks with no college education, history degrees, electrical engineering degrees, etc. Folks that have come up through the help desk, through the data center, through bootcamps, etc.
Let’s make that even easier to do.
I agree, I guess the context of the meme made it look like I was saying people need a 4 year degree, but I don’t believe that. It helps, but it’s not necessary at all.
I was mainly saying I don’t think a transitional master and apprentice setup would be easily workable
I agree that an apprentice working with a single “master” probably wouldn’t work very well. But I’m also not sure how frequently other apprenticeships still operate on that model. Perhaps it’s more common for other trades due to a preponderance of independent contractors, but there’s no saying that the apprentice needs to be beholden to one individual “master.”
This already exists through college coop programs, and people can end a coop program with work experience and not much debt.
The problem with special programs being kicked down to high school is it creates scarcity further down the chain, meaning kids need to make their life choices early and following through depends on availability.
You fix the problem of program capacity and sure that’s great.
Certainly I’m not suggesting that IT-related majors should be removed from universities or anything like that. Just that the main path into the industry shouldn’t cost dozens of thousands of dollars and take several years of an adult’s life.
We’ve already got all of these other, cheaper, faster paths into the industry. What if they were better? What if they were more popular? More available? How would that change the industry? Change society?
You seem to suggest it would be a bad thing (or maybe I’m misunderstanding), can you expand upon on that? I’m not sure I’m following.
Are you saying entry level positions will be monopolized by recent high school grads and no one else will be able to get jobs? If so, are they currently monopolized by recent boot camp grads? Recent college grads? Is one necessarily better than the other? Or necessarily worse?
Does a kid graduating from a trade school and scoring a job on a help desk, studying on the job for a CCNA, and moving onto the network engineering team take any food out of the mouth of the slightly older kid graduating with a CS degree and starting a job at the same company they did their internship? What about the 35 year old tired of working at the mailroom of a law firm who signs up for a bootcamp where a contracting company will pay them for the duration of the training and place them in a job with one of their clients for one year?
I’m not talking about IT, or the workforce, I’m talking about equal access to education.
Wealthier children that monopolize access to the higher specialisation courses is a thing that could happen, and I could see colleges and universities start to require those as prerequisites for certain degrees.
There’s a lot of work that would need to be done to remove barriers to education, which is the thing that we want to do in offering an alternative credential to enter the workforce. Doing this work in the wrong way would reinforce income disparity, reduce class mobility. We are talking about big changes.
I’ll chime in with a comment above, but I am an apprenticeship mentor at a big tech company, and while you are somewhat correct, most apprenticeship schemes will mix in academic learning alongside on-the-job training.
It’s a great way to learn if you are motivated. If you’re not, it’s immensely stressful compared to studying for a degree.
That sounds perfect actually
I went to college for certification in c++ instead of a full degree.
$15k/year raises? What industry? I’m in the wrong field! I’m lucky if my annual evaluation gets me a COL adjustment, much less an actual raise.
I hear that HVAC payscales are pretty nuts. The trick apparently is putting yourself back on the market at the start of each summer season – there are never enough HVAC people when July comes around.
To combat heat, I built a cooled water loop tubing into a breathable one piece suit, I like to say I got the idea from NASA to get people to not worry about my dress attire when I arrive. Wikipedia has it under the name liquid cooled garment.
You guys see what I’m talking about? HVAC people. Forged in the summer heat until they become monsters
My experience of being on an apprenticeship (UK, a decade ago) was very negative.
TL;DR I was paid under minimum wage to do the work of an otherwise normal employee whilst not receiving any sort of training, or even any valuable experience really outside of “generic office job experience”. Eventually it progressed into me getting horribly overworked on top of attempted pressure to get me to do additional work which was not part of my job description. My apprenticeship agency (an external company which is meant to oversee the apprenticeship) did nothing to help me.
Full Story:
I was hired by a furniture logistics company, essentially filling in Excel spreadsheets so that our warehouse could pick out the correct furniture and put it in the correct vans. There were originally two people doing this job but they were very overworked so they decided to hire an apprentice to ease the pressure.
I basically was paid under minimum wage to do the exact same job as my two coworkers. Eventually one of my coworkers left for a job elsewhere so it was only me and one coworker left doing work that my employers already knew was too much work for two people (whilst I still continued to be paid under minimum wage).
On top of this my employer tried to add more work onto me by getting me doing customer service work (receiving calls from angry customers who hadn’t received the correct furniture). This was not part of the job description. I asked if I could go on a formal training course with my apprenticeship agency on how to handle customers and phone calls before I took on this responsibility (I had not received any sort of training in any of my work responsibilities).
In the meantime I was constantly messing up my spreadsheets because I was overworked and lacked experience and training, resulting in the wrong furniture getting delivered (a wardrobe could have a item ID of something like 123456788 and a set of drawers could have an item ID of 123456789 so it was easy to make mistakes when rushing).
This alongside my refusal to take on extra work through phone calls got me fired. This, I don’t think, is actually legal. You’re not meant to be able to fire apprentices for being crap at their job because they should be expected to be crap. You can only fire them for something grievous like turning up to work drunk.
I contacted my apprenticeship agency to describe the situation and that I had been fired unfairly. The apprenticeship agency said they “didn’t want to take any sides” so they “weren’t going to do anything” (essentially as good as taking the side of my now ex-employers).
I ended up going to university doing a Computer Sciences degree and I’m now £70k in debt with the interest added being much larger than what I can pay back. :/
Maybe my initial mistake with my apprenticeship was not doing something vocational and just doing some generic office work. Kinda wish I could go back in time and become a plumber or an electrician or something.
Edit: Grammar
UK businesses abuse the apprenticeship system for profit.
Like fucking Subway were taking on apprentices. Because making a sandwich clearly takes years of training, rather than about a day. Nothing to do with being able to pay them half the minimum wage, oh no, can’t be that.
But then “not in my job description” is something I stopped hearing when I left school. In the real world, your job is what your boss tells you to do (within reason), otherwise you don’t have a job any more.
Yeah absolutely. The good apprenticeships which give you valuable skills and experience are few and far between, and the ones that also pay you fairly are even rarer and I imagine are more contested than a place at university.
In the real world, your job is what your boss tells you to do (within reason), otherwise you don’t have a job any more.
Yes, it’s true. I actually had another job between my apprenticeship ending and going to university where the job description was handing out leaflets. That was absolutely not what the job actually was so when I stubbornly refused to do nothing more than hand out my leaflets I got fired from that too.
I was but a bright-eyed 18 year old back then what can I say <\3 these days my spirit is crushed and I just do what I’m told (but at least I get paid a lot as a software developer).
The apprenticeship thing and pay scales only work when you’re talking about union jobs in skilled trades. Which are very hard to come by.
I’m not knocking blue-collar jobs–all labor deserves to be paid a living, and thriving, wage–but that’s not an honest assessment.
This is correct, but it’s virtually impossible to get most desk jobs without a degree.
Not because the degree is important, only because it’s a requirement.
So if you can afford it, unfortunately, I would recommend the degree path.
It does show you’ll stick with something for 4 years.
36,000? I broke 6 figures in debt.
Here’s one for you: Decide you want to apprentice at 35 because the career path you initially chose didn’t pan out, the market became saturated, or you burned out. See how far that gets you.
Maybe in America…
Here you have 5 years of free college for bachelor and 5 years free for masters.
