- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/34153611
Title text:
You say no human would reply to a forum thread about Tom Bombadil by writing and editing hundreds of words of text, complete with formatting, fancy punctuation, and two separate uses of the word ‘delve’. Unfortunately for both of us, you are wrong.
Transcript:
Transcript will show once it’s been added to explainxkcd.com
Source: https://xkcd.com/3126/
Did you use em dashes?
No—do you?
I do—they’re great!
I like to think of them as Mmmmm 💕—dashes!
You’d think I would have learned the keyboard shortcut by now, but no, I’m just really fast at opening the Character Map and copying it manually. I’ve found a number of useful symbols to add to my random comments & SMS messages in there. I’m just a regular μblogger, truly. If I spent ⅒ of the time I spend making random comments actually solving worthwhile problems, I’d be rich. Or happy. Or… something like that. C’est la vie. At least I know the difference between Unicode U+02D7, U+2010 – U+2015, U+2043, U+2212, and U+2E3A. There are more, but I really need sleep more than I need to find every horizontal line in all of Unicode.
</adhd>
Compose key and 3 minus signs for an em dash. Compose key, 2 minus signs, and a space for an en dash
if that’s a reference to something I don’t know it
In typography there are three distinct lengths of dash-like symbols:
Traditionally em dashes are used for punctuation—such as to separate clauses where the second clause expands on the first.
En dashes are used for ranges, like 1–7, or to join words or phrases together.
Hyphens are used within words, such as to indicate compound-words.
I think people were more particular about these uses when using typewriters. Like you could type two hyphens, and that would get you the same length as an em dash, and would look like one continuous symbol.
Nowadays the hyphen is the only easy dash to type, and it doesn’t look like one continuous line when typed twice. So instead of using an em dash people often use a hyphen with spaces around it, and people tend to use hyphens for ranges too. But ChatGPT knows the typography rules, and it likes to be technically correct.
I’ll note that I’ve just found that on Android you can get em or en dashes pretty easily by showing symbols, and then doing a long-press on the hyphen symbol.
———
Not written by ChatGPT, I’m just like this
Crap I’ve been doing it wrong. I just use a regular hyphen - like this…
That’s not true in general. I personally use the German Extended (E1) layout (when I’m not on mobile) and the em dash is super easy to type. There are also lots of other custom layouts used by people who care about typesetting.
Even people that don’t internationally care about typesetting sometimes use them because their tool (like Word and some CMS systems) automatically replace hyphens in specific places with em dashes, or substitute straight double quotes with the correct quotation marks (depending on which country you are from)
I care more about typesetting than the average feller, but LaTeX lets you use three hyphens (
---) to form an em-dash. Didn’t know any layouts had a key/chord for 'em.And on macOS, you can usually get an en dash with option dash and em dash with shift option dash
LLMs are likely to use em dashes appropriately and some people argue this indicates the usage of such a tool.
Which is obviously complete BS. I often use em dashes when I’m not on mobile, my keyboard layout typically is German Extended (E1) which makes them (and many other symbols needed for propper typesetting) accessable pretty easily.
Em dashes are not a sign of AI, but a sign of propper typesetting. They can be a tell if somebody didn’t use them before and randomly started using them in emails. But if you don’t know somebody and their tools or style of writing saying that they used Chat GPT because they used em dashes is completely ridiculous.