Office space meme:

“If y’all could stop calling an LLM “open source” just because they published the weights… that would be great.”

  • Maalus@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    11
    ·
    1 day ago

    Never have I used open source software that has achieved that, or was even close to achieving it. Usually it is opinionated (you need to do it this way in this exact order, because that’s how we coded it. No, you cannot do the same thing but select from the back), lacks features and breaks. Especially CAD - comparing Solidworks to FreeCAD for instance, where in FreeCAD any change to previous ops just breaks everything. Modelling software too - Blender compared to 3ds Max - can’t do half the things.

    • jj4211@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      9
      ·
      edit-2
      1 day ago
      • 7-zip
      • VLC
      • OBS
      • Firefox did it only to mostly falter to Chrome but Chrome is largely Chromium which is open source.
      • Linux (superseded all the Unix, very severely curtailed Windows Server market)
      • Nearly all programming language tools (IDEs, Compilers, Interpreters)
      • Essentially all command line ecosystem (obviously on the *nix side, but MS was pretty much compelled to open source Powershell and their new Terminal to try to compete)

      In some contexts you aren’t going to have a lively enough community to drive a compelling product even as there’s enough revenue to facilitate a company to make a go of it, but to say ‘no open source software has acheived that’ is a bit much.

    • Test_Tickles@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      1 day ago

      While I completely agree with 90% of your comment, that first sentence is gross hyperbole. I have used a number of pieces of open source options that are are clearly better. 7zip is a perfect example. For over a decade it was vastly superior to anything else, open or closed. Even now it may be showing its age a bit, but it is still one of the best options.
      But for the rest of your statement, I completely agree. And yes, CAD is a perfect example of the problems faced by open source. I made the mistake of thinking that I should start learning CAD with open source and then I wouldn’t have to worry about getting locked into any of the closed source solutions. But Freecad is such a mess. I admit it has gotten drastically better over the last few years, but it still has serious issues. Don’t get me wrong, I still 100% recommend that people learn it, but I push them towards a number of closed source options to start with. Freecad is for advanced users only.