Yep. Feel like we just had some posts about this. People who write that kind of backstory should just write a book. It’s especially bad in games like D&D where you’re starting out as a level 1 nobody. Some games, even some games of D&D, start at higher power levels, so the story is at least mechanically plausible.
I personally get pissed when I ask for advice how much backstory is ok for game starting at level 3 or 5 and people still tell me to be dumb nobody who doesn’t know how to hold a sword, even though that makes no fucking sense.
I believe Brian Murphy said you can write that backstory for a D&D character and make it work if it’s a comedy and all of that greatness is just in your character’s head. I don’t get to play much but tried to take a similar mindset: my character isn’t as badass as they think they are.
I think the “they think they’re a hero but they’re just level 1” trope goes in the same bucket as “let’s make characters based on ourselves!”. Everyone comes up with it but it’s rarely as good as imagined.
Yep. Feel like we just had some posts about this. People who write that kind of backstory should just write a book. It’s especially bad in games like D&D where you’re starting out as a level 1 nobody. Some games, even some games of D&D, start at higher power levels, so the story is at least mechanically plausible.
I personally get pissed when I ask for advice how much backstory is ok for game starting at level 3 or 5 and people still tell me to be dumb nobody who doesn’t know how to hold a sword, even though that makes no fucking sense.
I believe Brian Murphy said you can write that backstory for a D&D character and make it work if it’s a comedy and all of that greatness is just in your character’s head. I don’t get to play much but tried to take a similar mindset: my character isn’t as badass as they think they are.
I think the “they think they’re a hero but they’re just level 1” trope goes in the same bucket as “let’s make characters based on ourselves!”. Everyone comes up with it but it’s rarely as good as imagined.