Sounds like meta’s judge will have to invent a grand unified theory of fair use to excuse this.
I kept saying about various lawsuits that the important thing is discovery. Nobody knew all the idiotic shit these folks were doing, so nobody could sue them properly.
@themeatbridge
P2P may not care but a mega-corporation ought to care about who they might be making the files available to. Using a P2P tool doesn’t make it any better than putting it on an open FTP server at Facebook.com.
P2P isn’t the target here so your knee-jerk defensive posture is misplaced.
I mean, arguably an open FTP server would have been better because how many kids these days could actually use an FTP client?
About as many as a bittorrent client, i.e. a rounding error.
I agree with you, and fuck Facebook for a variety of reasons. I’m not defending Meta in the slightest. Nor is the allegation even false. Meta employees seeded porn to improve their torrent ratios and increase the speed with which they downloaded unlicensed copyrighted content to train their AI models. That porn was available to anyone with access to the seed, including likely minors.
My point is that the pearl-clutching Helen Lovejoy act is a bit much. The last time I downloaded p2p porn was probably on Bearshare and it included a bonzi buddy, and I was a minor at the time, but I’m not going to pretend that it’s some line in the sand. I’m not going to apply a different moral standard to Facebook than I apply to myself or anyone else.
Focus on what they did, which is bad enough, and don’t frame it in a way that provides the “but everybody does it” defense.
P2P vs FTP or whatever is not the point. Subtitling the article “Lawsuit: Meta may have seeded porn to minors while hiding piracy for AI training.” (emphasis mine) is misleading as it implies they were seeding the files with the intention or purpose to make them available to children.
Also, I find it disingenuous to pretend like seeding a torrent originally published by someone else is the same thing as publishing the file on an FTP site yourself, even if there’s legal precedent for treating it that way. Even if the bytes of the file are flowing out from your computer, that doesn’t mean you’re the one who made the file available, “to minors” or otherwise.