• 1 Post
  • 889 Comments
Joined 9 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 19th, 2024

help-circle





  • the people who make posts like this one would then claim that “work or eat boring food” counts as coercion.

    The food doesn’t need to be boring. But even under that assumption, it would still be less coercive, and therefore better.

    All of that takes an enormous amount of labour to produce.

    It sure does, but we live in a time of historically unheard of automation and excess. Over a century ago Kropotkin calculated a 5 hour work day/300hr work year to be the minimum needed per worker. And we’ve had a shit load of technicological advances since then. Even with the increases in amenities I’d be shocked if the true current number isn’t drastically lower.

    And your examples are all examples of things that people would genuinely like to work on. For example Mr. Technology connections is obsessed with heat pumps. I’m working on open source games, even while currently living under the coercion of capitalism. And I wouldn’t mind putting significant time into working to maintain a nation park, so long as it didn’t mean that it fucked with my food, shelter, and healthcare.





  • or even want to do the dirty jobs like trash removal

    Not to nitpick, but I don’t think that would be the case. We’re ultimately talking about building a society where everyone’s needs are met regardless of what they do, end game communism. And I think you’d still see people like this:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JahXgey1sK4

    For the lazy, it’s a group called Pedal People. They go around collecting trash in their city on bicycles with bike trailers, and they haul a respectable quantity of trash, recyclables, compost, etc. They do get payed, around $33 an hour, and it’s a co-op.

    Even in a true communist society with no money and all needs met, people like this would still exist. These people legitimately enjoy their jobs collecting trash on bikes, sustainably, even in the snow and heat. And it’s not the money that’s the only point for them. They’re doing a good service, getting exercise, have direct control over their labor, etc.

    Replace that paycheck with a society that respects their work with ample food, shelter, healthcare, etc and they probably would still be doing this. People like to be useful and helpful, we’re social creatures that evolved to live in communities.

    We just need communities that don’t threaten each other, and instead let people do what they can do to be useful.