• 72 Posts
  • 1.67K Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 6th, 2025

help-circle

  • Right now, it sounds like your are saying sending this person back to SF and sending the person next to her back to Saudi Arabia is the same.

    No, you are demanding that I say that in order for her to ‘deserve’ asylum. I’m saying ‘are they literally in Saudi Arabia?’ is a shit standard.

    If someone’s life is threatened because of where they live, they should be able to apply for asylum.

    Its a shitty system but how likely that person is to die or worse if they go back should definitely be part of the thought process.

    Again, do you believe that someone is likely to survive being run over by a truck? Her life has already been endangered, you just don’t take that danger seriously because it happened in San Francisco.





  • but I have trouble imagining it being that bad in SF.

    Why? Los Angeles last year had the largest number of hate crimes reported against trans people since they started tracking in 1980, and 90% of them were violent. California isn’t a queer utopia with no bigots.

    and some people applying are actually expecting death or worse if they go back.

    You would expect to live if someone succeeded in running you over with a truck, as was attempted on the woman the article is about?

    we aren’t at that point yet, at least not in San Fransisco.

    Unless you’re trans and in SF, you’re pulling this out of your ass.