• Zozano@lemy.lol
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      edit-2
      3 months ago

      I don’t think there’s an ethical basis for capital punishment, except under some extreme circumstance (like having intel that a militant force will raid a prison to rescue a high ranking war criminal).

      There are multiple reasons:

      1. Surprisingly, capital punishment is expensive. So expensive in fact, that it’s cheaper to keep them in prison for their entire life, multiple times over.

      2. The capacity for someone to suffer ends when they die. If you believe in punishment (I don’t, but you do you), then it makes sense to prolong their suffering as long as possible.

      3. Capital punishment doesn’t dissuade criminals. Countries with capital punishment have just as many criminals as those without.

      4. Punishment is a shitty metric by all accounts. Harm mitigation is the aim of the game, whether you’re talking about prison or execution, they’re both isolating a person from the broader community. If the prison serves the same purpose, why do we need execution?

      5. It’s unrealistic to employ capital punishment where there isn’t any. Anyone who deserves to be executed would not be released from prison. You’ve got a better chance of convincing people to prolong prison punishments than you do of instating legal murder.

      6. Innocent people are wrongfully convinced every day. Many people have been executed, only to be found innocent some years later.

    • DarkThoughts@fedia.io
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      3 months ago

      What in the hell about my comment is rage bait? lol Over the years we’ve had countless of news articles about priests, pedo hunters and other highly “outspoken” individuals getting caught with child pornography or a history of raping children. It’s always the same pattern.

      Death penalty = barbarism. Murder is only okay if there’s no other option, like a trapped you vs me scenario, or a violent dictator like Hitler who can’t be removed through other means, etc. And I already live in a civilized country so it already is abolished.

    • Zozano@lemy.lol
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      3 months ago

      What the other poster was getting at, which I was going to bring up is they said there’s a difference between a paedophile and a child molester.

      A child molester is a criminal, a paedophile is not.

      Don’t get the wrong idea, this isn’t a defence of paedophiles, but defence of a demographic of people who haven’t done anything wrong.

      Much of the reason paedophiles dont seek help is because of the mindset displayed here.

      A paedophile who commits themselves to never touching a child is nothing short of a hero in my opinion.