Uh… They’re not the same thing? 🤔
Got two wheels? Electrically powered? That’s an electronic bicycle. 🤷♂️
Personally I don’t understand why anyone would need even 750W for an electric bike, let alone multiple kilowatts.
Mine is an EU-regulation 250W and I never even use the top power level. In fact sometimes I forget to turn on the battery and (on the flat) don’t even notice.
This really looks like the same story of macho horsepower inflation that’s been at work with combustion motorbikes for a century. Look at those giant BMWs with 1.4-litre engines that are enough to power a sedan. Completely unnecessary and irrational (and non-existent just a few decades ago) but the biker-dude owners will always find a reason that they “need” it. And let’s face it, this really is a story about dudes.
A few routes near me have banned e-bikes, which is frustrating because I’m sure the real problem is the 15 year olds on illegal electric motorbikes. Not e-bikes.
My state changed their max power from 750w continuous to 750w peak, which turned my bicycle into a motorcycle.
If I’d known I was going to be breaking the law, I’d have bought something more powerful, damn it.
What’s really stupid about limiting e-bikes by wattage is that it discriminates against cargo bikes. Limiting by capping assisted top speed makes much more sense.
Acceleration and top speed both need to be controlled if they are to be bikes. Watts puts too much incentive to cheat.
Bosch seems to did pretty well with their cargobike mid-drive. If you’re a cargobike maker you’d want a mid-drive anyway.
Any parents reading this who’ve found themselves with an unwanted electric motorcycle, I’d be happy to take it off your hands.
As with everything, parents refuse to do any research and just buy whatever for their children. Next steps will be attempting to ban them.
I know tech nerds scoff about this for video games and, in this case, e-bikes; but I imagine when you’re buying so many categories of item for kids, there’s always something you don’t think about enough - especially if, being a parent, your time is at a premium.
I’m not trying to shoulder blame 100% on manufacturers, just describing why it’s an understandable mistake to me.
Video games have ratings right on the box, ebikes have top speeds written on them. I put the blame on the parents.
Ban parents? Only sensible take.
Right? How fucking hard is it to just fucking google something like this, in this day and age? It’s not like the 80s and 90s where you had to call around to find information about something your kid wants. You can just look it up online, easily. Epitome of shit parents.
I have to imagine it’s easier than starting a coalition to ban things, but I’ve been wrong about that before
Listen, Google is new technology. It was only invented 30+ years ago…
Putting aside that the internet definitely existed in the 80s and 90s. That’s what magazines were for, that’s why there was a zine for everything.
I mean, it wasn’t exactly widely available and the average household didn’t have Internet until the mid to late 90s, and a lot of times it was a shared line, so if Mom was taking to Great Aunt Millie for the first time in months, you weren’t getting online that night lol.
Even a quick googling on my end got me results for what I’m hoping is a suitable kid’s e-bike. Class 2 (20mph max), 500W, and cargo space for any bulky school projects.
The weird thing for me is that where I live, lots of these middle school kids ride them on the sidewalks that run along the greenbelt area and absolutely refuse to ride them in the grass even to go around people. If I were riding something like a pseudo dirt bike you couldn’t keep me off the grass.
Legally they’re supposed to ride in the street. Not the grass, or the sidewalk.
UPDATE: To clarify, this post was written with Class 1-3 ebikes in mind. Anything above that is absolutely subject to motorcycle regulations. Registration, insurance, etc.
If you mean the breakdown lane, then yes… assuming it exists on that road. If not, then you really don’t have a choice. Speaking from experience, riding on a 3-6 inch mini road shoulder is a horrible experience. You’re constantly checking for cars behind while simultaneously making sure you don’t bonk the sidewalk curb which will topple you if you hit it.
My path list is breakdown lane > parking lot > sidewalk > dirt. Whatever keeps me clear of both pedestrians and moving cars.
Where I live it’s illegal to ride bikes (or e-scooters) on the sidewalk. You are required to ride in the street and observe traffic laws like stop signs.
Oh dear god please tell me that’s in an area with both respectful drivers and a sufficiently low 15-20 mph speed limit. All of my defensive driving experience is screaming DANGER.
There is an area like that near where I live, and it is the only place where I feel it is safe to even consider mingling with car traffic. For that area, I do exactly as you posted.
They are motorcycles - they need to be ridden in the same lane as cars. You also need a drivers license with a motorcycle endorsement - which I doubt most kids have. (check your state laws, you may need to be 18 to get the motorcycle endorsement)
In my state only class one bikes (pedal assist, assist stops at 20mph) may be ridden in bike lanes or shared use paths). Each state has different laws though so check yours (and check again next year as the laws are changing)
I think we might be confusing bike types. The one I have checks out under the Class 3 e-bike specs. 28 mph max, 750W sustained motor, and no license or plates needed.
Anything above that is absolutely a motorcycle though, and will need license and registration.
there are 3 different ebike types. In my state only class one or two may be used on bike paths and sidewalks (class 2 also allowed when limited to 12mph top speed - the article says 20mph…) Class 3 is not allowed on bike paths and sidewalks, you don’t need a drivers license but you must be at least 16 to use them. laws may be different in your state though, so check first.
In any case this article is about bikes that don’t even meet the class 3 limits. They are motorcycles and you need license and registration - which you may not be able to get (to get registration I think you need a VIN which these probably don’t have - but then again I haven’t checked either the laws much less if these bikes meet those laws)
Shit, I ride my folding bicycle on grass and the tires are only 1.75".
I think this is my biggest issue with ebikes.
People will be riding down the mixed use pedestrian/bike pathway on what looks like a bike, going 45mph next to the road with a 35mph speedlimit without peddaling.
I think there needs to be some regulation that makes it more visually apparent what is an electric bike and what is an electric motorcycle.
riding down the mixed use pedestrian/bike pathway on what looks like a bike, going 45mph
Much as I hate to say it, problems like this have a way of solving themselves. The unfortunate thing is they usually take some innocent bystander down with them.
Call me crazy, but maybe we should try to solve obvious problems before people are injured/maimed/killed.
I’m sure the kids will be distraught by the mistake!
And some will end up dead because they wore a bicycle helmet on something that can go 65mph.
Give a normal acoustic bike a steep enough hill and you can get to 65mph. Note that I said you: I won’t try this, but someone else could - they might even survive the attempt.
65 is tough. Fastest I’ve gone on a bike is 50 mph, and it was terrifying.
Sure, but that’s pretty restricted to specific geography most people would have to travel to, and not the road outside thier home.
The first time I rode a dirt bike I panicked and crashed into a chain link fence. Going maybe 5 mph, and that was with adult supervision. I hate to think what will happen to these children who are accidentally given a road vehicle because the regulations are currently inadequate.
🥺💔💀
Happening around me and one of them is going to be squashed like a bug based on how they are riding them.
