Maybe. Like I said, the overall body language from the dog, and his tone of voice when he talks about her, and also him lying about objectively verifiable things, mean more to me on the topic than a lot of these clips that people are talking about.

(For example, the fact that back then he was saying that shock collars are mean and he doesn’t believe in them, and he’s bringing that up now as a defense of himself, but then saying simultaneously that shock collars don’t even hurt anyway so even if she was wearing one it wouldn’t be a big deal. That’s… well, you know.)

But anyway, like I say, I have never seen someone’s dog who is less happy to interact with them. She just seems defeated. She doesn’t lick him, she doesn’t perk up when he pays attention to her, she just sits there quietly while he’s rubbing her head or whatever, and then slowly obeys his commands to come here or go sit on her bed or whatever, with her head down. I realize that’s subjective but that is definitely my take on it.