I use both in a balanced way.

I save a lot of videos in my custom private youtube playlist. And those logs is saved within my Google account automatically. Nothing happens if I uninstall the app itself by mistake or clear its data.

Whereas in Newpipe, it doesn’t have a gmail account integration feature. Even though, it does have its custom playlist builder setting and also have the option to backup the entire streaming activity and playlists as a whole.

But everything’s gone if someday, by mistake, the app gets uninstalled or its data get cleared without backing up in prior.

The only 1 big reason I use Newpipe is for it’s external download feature. I can download a video as external .mp3, .mp4 and in other formats.

To be fair, Newpipe does almost all the things that Revanced YT provides.

But I just don’t happen to be the kind of guy to create a manual backup every 24 hours just to keep track of what I’m watching. At least, not for now.

Maybe when I won’t be needing to update my watch time with my playlist, then I can fully shift to Newpipe. But Until then…

I use Grayjay. Good UI, no microg and multiple streaming sources. I only don’t like how big this app is.

ReVanced is just the way to go for me. Good UI is a requirement, and sponsorblock and return YT dislike integration is a must have

i don’t like having microg in the background so I use pipepipe, seems to work well enough. (and i don’t watch much youtube)

Grayjay is hands down the best

i like revanced cause i can log on and use it just like the official app but without ads :)

New Pipe is okay, but Pipe Pipe is better. Revanced is not on fdroid IIRC

I use ReVanced because I like having my subscriptions and having unknown content recommended to me. Even though the algorithm has been especially shitty in the last few months. Maybe I’ll switch after all.

I use FreeTube and NewPipe. But Google just broke them. Even yt-dlp needed to implement a JavaScript engine.

I’m using ReVanced in the meantime but I’m not enjoying it. It’s good as a backup I suppose as it’s better than using YouTube through a browser.

Here’s my guide for installing ReVanced via obtainium, just incase it can be useful for someone

• install the following in obtainium

  • https://github.com/ReVanced/revanced-manager/
  • https://github.com/ReVanced/GmsCore/

• download the suggested version of the official YouTube apk

  • https://youtube.en.uptodown.com/android/download/1102578123

• launch revanced manager, patch the YouTube apk, then install the patched apk.

• go to YouTube app info and select it to be able to open YouTube links by default

Edit: just used PipePipe for the first time. It works and seems like a better alternative than YouTube ReVanced to me.

I use Grayay. I’ve found it more consistent/reliable than NewPipe and, like you, I don’t want the YouTube app on my phone (even if it has been modded). Also, I just don’t believe using cracked/modded versions of official applications is a good long-term solution to problems. ReVanced works really well but it is basically the last choice I would make, for that reason.

I’m using Tubular, a NewPipe fork.

Based on this thread I’m trying out PipePipe

I use the mobile site through Firefox so I can block the ads with extensions

I like libretube because it has the nicest interface and works well

Don’t like Youtube’s design choices, too bloated and the little you can configure is all over the place. NewPipe from the little I used it was a bit noisy, but felt like it better used the space than YT, and also had integration to a few other services.

NewPipe or a fork. I personally use PipePipe. The interface is much nicer than anything else, no over the top “modern” design, just simple and functional.