Idk if this will come out with the right meaning in english, but imo when somebody is using something like a LLM they are more like a manager in a factory/office than a film/music director.
I think it definitely depends on the level of involvement and the intent. Sure not everybody who just asks for something to be made for them is doing much directing. But someone who does a lot of refinement and curation of AI generated output needs to demonstrate the same kind of creativity and vision as an actual director.
I guess I’d say telling an artist to do something doesn’t make you a director. But a director telling an AI to do the same kinds of things they’d tell an artist doesn’t suddenly make them not a director.
i’m in this thread coming off as very anti-AI art but i think it absolutely can have a place in the creative process. even as part of the finished work.
but if it’s the whole process then there’s no creation at all. just recycling slop.
I’m fairly certain most people consider directing (film, music, art, etc) to be an artistic process.
Idk if this will come out with the right meaning in english, but imo when somebody is using something like a LLM they are more like a manager in a factory/office than a film/music director.
I think it definitely depends on the level of involvement and the intent. Sure not everybody who just asks for something to be made for them is doing much directing. But someone who does a lot of refinement and curation of AI generated output needs to demonstrate the same kind of creativity and vision as an actual director.
I guess I’d say telling an artist to do something doesn’t make you a director. But a director telling an AI to do the same kinds of things they’d tell an artist doesn’t suddenly make them not a director.
i’m in this thread coming off as very anti-AI art but i think it absolutely can have a place in the creative process. even as part of the finished work.
but if it’s the whole process then there’s no creation at all. just recycling slop.