• 0 Posts
  • 482 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle






  • Agreed, it presents as an abstract logic puzzle, but then gives a very concrete answer. It’s like presenting the trolly problem to someone, and when they give one of the two expected answers saying “no, stupid, you run ahead and untie the victims before the trolly reaches them.”

    It’s compounded by the fact that the proposed physical solution isn’t even very reliable, as lots of people in this thread have said. If we’re stepping outside of the logic puzzle constraints, why not just leave the door to the room open? Or have someone stand inside and shout when the light turns on? Or ask someone who knows these switches? Or any number of boring non-brain teaser solutions.








  • Yeah, I get it - an insane number of people have been Dracula, you need to limit the list somehow. But especially when we’re less than a year out from the Egger’s Nosferatu, I think people will really want to have that one available. And if that’s on the list, it’d be weird not to include the original, since it’s so historic and iconic.

    So I think I’d include those two but, despite what I said about the names, maybe you can skip '79 just on the grounds that it’s very aesthetically similar to the '22 version? Picturing the list those two side by side might feel redundant, whereas Egger’s version has a much more distinct look.

    But it’s all debatable. And the end of the day, we’ve just been spoiled by too many Draculas.



  • Feedback on your selection:

    I’d drop the Draculas from Dracula III and Blade III. Neither of those are exactly beloved films. Then you have room to slip in the new 2025 Dracula and Van Helsing’s without expanding to 15.

    If you do want a few options to expand, I’d suggest: Claes Bang (BBC/Netflix 2020), Duncan Regehr (Monster Squad), and Keith-Lee Castle (Young Dracula). They’re all a bit more on the silly side and none would necessarily be my choice, but I feel like they might be someone’s - especially if they grew up watching the latter two.

    Also, regarding your choice to disinclude Nosferatu – the 1979 Nosferatu used the traditional Stoker names, including “Count Dracula”, so if your only objection is the name that remake should qualify. And it’s an absolutely beautiful film, definitely worth a watch (if unethical behind the scenes behaviour ruins films for you, though, I’d stay away from reading up on it…)

    My own choice:

    Joining the ranks of Gary Oldman lovers – although if it matched your criteria, Skarsgard would come out on top.