• 0 Posts
  • 38 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: August 3rd, 2023

help-circle
  • Why didn’t you include all of article II in your criteria?

    Here’s the beginning:

    In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religions group, as such:

    The intent and type of group being targeted are also part of the criteria.

    In this case it would be Israel intending to destroy, in whole or in part, Palestinians. Which South Africa is trying to prove in court using statements that Israeli politicians have made and the actions of the IDF.

    The intent is the most difficult element to determine. To constitute genocide, there must be a proven intent on the part of perpetrators to physically destroy a national, ethnical, racial or religious group. Archive of UN.org



  • From the article’s graph:

    September had the lowest number of lorries recorded since the first month of the war, with only 53 lorries per day

    I’m not sure how they got their numbers. I checked the Humdata site it shows 2905 trucks in September and 3096 trucks in August. Averaging around 97 and 100 trucks per day respectively. The article’s graph also shows May had more trucks than June which doesn’t match the data I saw.

    I think the data I linked is from the UN which is their stated source, maybe they’re filtering the data on some criteria.

    Edit: I was listening to the security council meeting concerning the middle east today. Algeria and United Kingdom representatives mentioned the lowest amount of humanitarian trucks entered last month since the start of the war. I found the UN report it’s from.

    According to OCHA, in September 2024, an average of only 52 humanitarian trucks entered the Gaza Strip per day. This is well below the pre-crisis average of 500 trucks per working day.

    The OCHA link has a graph at the bottom with the same data as the BBC article.








  • Go to Applebee’s and order Four-Cheese Mac & Cheese with honey pepper chicken tenders. The chicken tenders are excellent but the Mac and Cheese is the most watery garbage I’ve ever eaten. Then you will understand the true skill of making delicious Mac and Cheese.








  • I’m not saying they can’t prove it. They might be able to, the problem is connecting public statements to official Israeli policy.

    “I don’t think there are any innocents there now, not now and not when I said those things,” Vaturi said. 

    It’s not right, but he said this after an evacuation of the area.

    “I urge you to do everything and use Doomsday weapons fearlessly against our enemies,” Gotliv wrote on social media platform X, calling upon Israel to use “everything in its arsenal”.

    This is pretty vague and specifically mentions “enemies”

    In November, Galit Distel Atbaryan, Israel’s former public diplomacy minister, called for Gaza to be “erased from the face of the Earth”, stating that the besieged enclave should be “wiped out” by a “vengeful and vicious” Israeli army.

    This guy isn’t even in office, it is ironic he was a diplomacy minister

    Last week, lawmaker Moshe Saada said that widespread calls he had heard from the Israeli public to “destroy all Gazans” had proven that the “right-wing was right about the Palestinian issue”.

    This is a pretty good example but he never says that the right-wing policy is to destroy all Gazans, just that the public wants it.

    It’s not such an easy thing to prove. There are plenty of right-wing extremists in Israel’s government right now, it’s likely they have crossed the line with their rhetoric but rhetoric isn’t policy. I have yet to see any smoking gun evidence that Israel specifically intends to commit genocide (in a legal sense, not a moral or colloquial way).