What does “aware” mean, or “knowledge”? I think those are going to be circular definitions, maybe filtered through a few other words like “comprehend” or “perceive”.
Does a plant act with deliberate intention when it starts growing from a seed?
To be clear, my beef is more with the definition of “conscious” being useless and/or circular in most cases. I’m not saying “woah, what if plants have thoughts dude” as in the meme, but whatever definition you come up with, you have to evaluate why it does or doesn’t include plants, simple animals, or AI.
What does “aware” mean, or “knowledge”? I think those are going to be circular definitions, maybe filtered through a few other words like “comprehend” or “perceive”.
Does a plant act with deliberate intention when it starts growing from a seed?
To be clear, my beef is more with the definition of “conscious” being useless and/or circular in most cases. I’m not saying “woah, what if plants have thoughts dude” as in the meme, but whatever definition you come up with, you have to evaluate why it does or doesn’t include plants, simple animals, or AI.